Santa: Keeping the Magic, but Losing the Lies

December 1st, 2012

We talked to Miss Mouse about Santa Claus tonight.  And although the phrase “he’s not real” didn’t come out of my mouth exactly, that was the gist of the conversation.

The issue has been building in our house and in my heart for some time and I felt like we needed to address it.

I know that The Santa Debate is huge, with passionate defenders on both sides.  Let me say up front that I certainly don’t think that families who choose to go all-in with Santa are harming their kids — I have fond memories of huddling under a blanket with my cousin on Christmas Eve long after the parents were in bed, gazing at the clock on the thermostat and wondering if this would be the year when we’d get a peek at the magic reindeer.

But for lots of reasons, I ultimately decided I needed to be upfront with my kids about Santa.  Those reasons include:

  • Santa’s potential to eclipse Jesus as the Reason for the Season (issue #1 for my hubs);
  • The way that the Santa myth can hinder kids’ understanding of holiday philanthropy;
  • The disgusting amount of commercialism surrounding Santa, whose overarching message in advertising today is “gimme gimme gimme” ;
  • The inherent untruthfulness involved in embracing Santa with your family.


Some of those are self-explanatory, but let me hit briefly on the philanthropy thing as it only came to my attention this year.  Santa’s world-wide largess started to bug me when I heard several friends report that they’d had trouble “selling” their kids on participating in Operation Christmas Child because the kids couldn’t understand the concept of a gift-less Christmas.  After all, Santa magically delivers presents to every kid in the world.  Ergo, there are no children who don’t have gifts.  So why are we packing up shoe boxes again?

Good point, kids.

But mostly, my beef with Santa is in the lies.  Oh, the lies.

Look, I’m not going to pretend that I never lie to my kids.  I’ve told them that we didn’t have cookies when really I just didn’t want to share mine.  And I’ve said that certain obnoxious toys “broke” when really I took out their batteries.  I’m a mom.  We do that.

But something about the systematic web of falsehood that accompanies the Santa story bugged me.  My daughter is so trusting and so believing, I had a hard time making myself say the necessary fibs when the topic came up.  It just made me feel yucky.

Miss Mouse isn’t even old enough to be asking pointed questions.  But she DOES say things like: “Santa is going to bring me presents!

You can’t remain neutral in that moment.  Either you say, “yes, he is” which isn’t true, or you say “no, he isn’t” which requires explanation.  Or she’ll innocently ask: “Mommy, how does Santa know what I want for Christmas?”  Taking on the role of Switzerland in the Santa wars is not an option.

So what to do about Santa?  I decided that I want to embrace the magic on an even playing field – one in which all players know there’s a game afoot.  I love Santa traditions like stockings and cookies and reindeer food sprinkled on the lawn.  I find all of that stuff completely and utterly magical.  I want my daughter to feel the same way, without being duped.

Tonight, we watched the Veggie Tales video about St. Nicholas and talked to Miss Mouse about Santa.  The message was this: Santa is a fun pretend game.  Sometimes we pretend that we’re princesses in a castle.  Sometimes we pretend to be ponies.  Sometimes we pretend to be hair stylists.  And sometimes we pretend that Santa Claus comes to our house with flying reindeer, bringing presents.

We actually didn’t go too much into St. Nicholas with Miss Mouse because the addition of a historical character seemed to confuse the narrative a bit and I could tell she wasn’t making the leap from St. Nicholas to Santa Claus.  We just talked about what we thought was most important at Christmas — Jesus, family, and the fun things we do together during the season.

To be perfectly honest, I’m not sure she “got” it.  I understand that.  At her age, the line between “real” and “pretend” is extremely porous.   Although I’ve never asked, it’s entirely possible she believes that Ariel and Belle are “real” too.

But at the end of the day, I believe Santa can be fun and magical without being “real.”  At least I hope so.

11 responses to “Santa: Keeping the Magic, but Losing the Lies”

  1. Anna Parkinson says:

    Thanks for blogging about this! As you know, it has been the subject of much conversation in my house lately.

  2. Karol says:

    Hey, this is really good! Why don’t you consider submitting it as a guest opinion to your favorite newspaper?

  3. Susan Breyer says:

    I completely agree. When I figured out about Santa Clause, I felt that everyone had lied to me. BTW I was 11. My parents never understood my anger.

    My problem with Santa with my own children was that I had too much ego to give Santa credit for my shopping and wrapping. Each child only got one unwrapped present that was near our fireplace from Santa.

    • Kate says:

      My own ah-ha moment with Santa was less traumatic, but I do still remember it! And I totally understand your point about not wanting Santa to get credit for the great gifts you carefully select for your kids!

  4. Mandy says:

    I agree Kate. When Tess was four years old she matter of factly said “I think Santa Claus is a fairy tale”. I was shocked but couldn’t bring myself to tell her she was wrong when she was right. Fairy tales and mythical characters are so great.

  5. G'Mom says:

    I remember my Mom saying The Wrong Thing one Christmas when I said something about you and stockings and Santa Claus. “What”, said my Mom (in front of you), you still believe in that?” I wanted to put a pillow over her face to make her stop talking! Was that your ah-ha moment?

    • Kate says:

      Ha ha ha. I don’t remember that at all but I can imagine your blood pressure must have spiked! No, my memories of the end of Santa revolve around Care Bears. I wanted more, they weren’t making them anymore, and “Santa” wrote me a letter saying the elves had lost the pattern…

  6. […] Last year, we decided that we weren’t going to “do the Santa thing” with the kids.  I had lots of reasons and you can read about them here. […]

Leave a Reply

Welcome to
Green Around the Edges

Thanks for stopping by! We can all agree that motherhood is a wild ride, full of smiles, tears, and oatmeal in your hair. But when life gets hectic, it's amazing how far you can get with a smile and a few tricks up your sleeve. I hope you leave here with both!


Subscribe to Green Around the Edges via email and get a
daily dose of humor and encouragement delivered right to your inbox.

  • Cast of Characters

    Miss Mouse Kung Fu PandaLittle Bird
  • Archives